Several weeks later Annie is invited to speak to a book discussion group and to participate in a murder mystery game put together by one of the members. As the game unfolds, Annie notices uncanny parallels to the day she and Brendan were forced off the road; it seems that someone else was present at the time. Seeing someone hadn't been her imagination. It also becomes evident that one of the players isn't playing at murder, but is deadly serious. It's up to Annie to discover why and whodunit.