Three of Hearts — Kelly Jamieson

But right before the last concert, Haylee discovers she's been dumped for a sexy girly girl. Story of her life: all guys see is tomboy Haylee. At the after-concert party, she drowns her sorrows and -- desperate to feel feminine for once in her life -- asks Ben and Lucas for a threesome. And it's just as sexy and fun as she hoped.

Back in Nashville, Ben and Lucas prove again and again that their first night wasn't a mistake. But the tension between them is still high, and on Christmas Eve, their ménage takes a stunning turn. When it all falls apart, Haylee is terrified that their crazy relationship might cost them the band, their success, and worst of all, each other.