The Boy Next Door — Wendy Storm

Christie thought all her dreams had come true. Steve Michaels, the best looking boy in school, had asked her to the dance - and she had finally gotten to dump Cliff Carson, the conceited idiot who lived next door.

But Christie was in for two surprises. The first was the night of the Spring Parade Moonlight Dance, when her prince turned into a toad. The second was when a guy she'd thought was a toad turned out to be...