If Wishes Were Horses — Barbara Morgenroth

If wishes were horses, that would explain all the horse manure. Caprice Rydell makes a wish, flips a coin into a fountain and her life changes. Her father is a bigamist and if that isn't embarrassing enough, it all happens in front of Mill Crocker, the gorgeous captain of the school polo team. Mill thinks she's adorable but wishing isn't reality and he thinks she's got what she wants. In a panic to right everything, what Cap wants is to reset her life back to normal again by getting that coin in her wet little hand. One more problem. Just how can she find it among the thousands in the fountain?