Gingerbread and Good Tidings — Kris T. Bethke

Cody Schaefer loves the Christmas season and a benefit to working from home means that he gets to be surrounded by his decoration collections all the time. And as a bonus, he starts getting deliveries from a local café containing holiday treats flavored with gingerbread. The notes aren't signed, but they clearly come from someone who knows him.

Out of all of Cody's friends, Jason van Buren is the only one level-headed about the mysterious treats, and Cody begins talking to him daily. Cody enjoys their chats, and the two men grow closer. One Christmas Eve, no delivery appears. But Jason shows up on his doorstep, ready to back gingerbread cookies. It's then Cody realizes just who is behind the deliveries. And perhaps, Cody will get Jason as his Christmas gift this year.