Small-Town Sweethearts — Jean C. Gordon

Summoned as temporary guardian for her teenage niece, Emily Hazard returns to Paradox Lake. On one condition -- she won't let herself think about staying. Emily always felt like a misfit in her tiny hometown.

But she doesn't count on falling for handsome Drew Stacey, a former Wall Streeter who's getting the town church camp ready. Though he surprises Emily with his handiness with tools, understanding of teenagers and his steady faith, she'll soon head back to New York. Unless her small-town sweetheart asks her to stay forever.