Unholy Matrimony — Brenda Barrett

The problem: Phoebe was poor and unhappy with her lot.
The solution: Marry a rich man and she would be happy.

It should be simple, except that her rich suitor, Ezekiel Hoppings, was ugly and her poor suitor, Charles Black, was handsome. But the more she got to know them both, the more Phoebe realized that some solutions were not as simple as they first appear.