It Had to Be You — B.G. Thomas

Robert Daniels is always dating the wrong guys. He doesn't understand it. Then, one day, on a particularly bad date, he dies…

…only to wake up in the body of  a man named Jimmy, who was shot and killed -- but in 1927. Along comes Hugh Naylor, the guy Robert has been waiting for all his life. Hugh is perfect -- sweet, intelligent, and sexy. The problem? Hugh is in love with Jimmy.

Now Robert's falling in love with Hugh, but how can he explain he isn't who he appears? How can he get Hugh to love him, and not the man whose body he inhabits? And who shot Jimmy?